twitter facebook stumble upon rss

My Son Speaks Pokemon

sign up for the momlogic newsletter Tweet This

Sabrina's Mom•Logic: Pokemon is confusing ... and a tad disconcerting.

pokemon.jpg

Mom•Logic's editor-in-chief Sabrina says: In case your child is 4 or under (or a girl), Pokemon = endless pricey decks of cards that have characters and numbers that somehow indicate each character's "power" and, to my son's somewhat-upsetting joy, the "damage" each can do.

The characters look cute, but according to my 6-year-old, they are in fact ferocious, shape-shifting warriors with stunning powers to kill or be killed. He sorts cards into piles and lines which we are forbidden to shift, lest we disturb the "battle" he has brewing between his cuddly-yet-somehow-fierce mutant bunny-mice.

Upon searching online for "Explain Pokemon," I found many confused parents asking "Is Pokemon sweet or super-violent?" Some even called it evil. Hmm. On the one hand, if my son spends an hour holding his hands above said cards in a séance-like fashion, it offers us a nice opportunity to read the Sunday Times while he's doing something that seems to involve higher-math.

On the other hand: what the frick is he doing? Seriously, I had previously considered myself the kind of person who could understand a card game. Can anyone help me out here? Comment or email me at Sabrina@momlogic.com.


next: Celebrity Crib Notes
10 comments so far | Post a comment now
Kristi February 12, 2008, 1:17 PM

You will be glad to know that your not the only one who has a child who speaks pokemon. When my son gets together with our neighbor or his cousin they begin to talk pokemon. It is really strange. I just don’t get it and don’t want to I guess. The show is so annoying but I would never tell him that. It is just a phase I hope.

Ambar February 12, 2008, 1:43 PM

My son is 9 and we have had pokemon, on again off again in our home for 4 years now. My husband and I still don’t understand it. We consider ourselves pretty hip, and have tried to sit down and “understand” it several times. Just last year he got the Pokemon Battle Revolution for the Wii system and we thought finally in game form on a screen bigger than 2 inches we might understand it. But no we still don’t get it. Sigh. It doesn’t seem to be going any where soon.

Todd February 12, 2008, 4:08 PM

Really, Pokemon isn’t that hard to understand. The video game was last year’s top seller if I remember correctly. The TV show is undergoing a resurgence and is on Cartoon Network. The card game has players of all ages from 5 to 65 and features a once a year event that brings together players from all over the globe. In fact the biggest competition is usually among the players who are 15 and up.

The basics idea behind Pokemon is that these critters (Pokemon = shortened form of Pocket Monster) form bonds of friendship with their “trainers.” Many of the trainers compete in various sorts of events much the way kids compete in Soccer or Tae Kwon do events. Pokemon don’t ever “kill” each other. The worst that ever happens after a “Pokemon Battle” is that they have to visit “Nurse Joy” at the equivalent of a first aid center after getting knocked out.

There is less violence in a typical Pokemon TV show than in any of the old style Road Runner cartoons you might have watched growing up. Pokemon stresses friendship, responsibility, healthy competition, and adventure. These are things that most kids eat up which is one reason why I think it stays popular. The difference is that instead of just having a TV show there is the modern multi-media blitz with the games, cards, toys, and more.

Sabrina February 12, 2008, 10:32 PM

Thanks Todd! Great explanation (and highly reassuring) I am printing this out so I’m ready for my kid’s next “battle”!

sarah February 12, 2008, 11:00 PM

Ok, I am 17 and I haven’t come here to rat on adults, but…the Pokemon trading card game has been around for years. I have been playing the game since the 3rd grade and I still managed to graduate early from high school, start college, and live a happy life. Pokemon is a card game with absolutely no violence. It is a game where two pokemon (pocket monsters) battle until one of them faints. It is specifically named fainting because a pokemon can be revived after it has fainted; therefore there is no death involved. Yes many have called it evil, but why? The stories that are presented in the Bible contain more violence than this card game. The Pokemon’s mutation is merely evolution. When a Pokemon reaches a certain level, it evolves and learns new attacks. Some attacks, such as sing, do nothing more than lull the opponent to sleep. There is always controversy over the Pokemon trading card game and that is understandable in the world we live in today, but…without that card game many children would resort to other hobbies that could result in a more violent attitude.

Anonymous February 15, 2008, 9:51 AM

this is gay

Evan Abeling February 17, 2008, 2:19 AM

Listen Sabrina. Pokemon is a game and absolutely nothing more. First of all, I suggest that you take your kid aside and tell him face to face that pokemon aren’t real. If he continues to talk as if pokemon are violent evil creatures that mutate into bigger and even scarier monsters that are bent on killing each other, than you should probably just take away pokemon for good. They aren’t important to his growth. In fact, they may get in the way of school and/or his social life at one point. I also suggest that you start him on something creative (such as music, theatre, or art) that will improve his depth in character instead of him thinking about a silly card game 24/7. I hope things work out well for you.

Shiny February 18, 2008, 9:23 PM

Pokemon is a great thing for children. If the child thinks they are evil and such, then tell him the truth. Just keep him on Pokemon, it even taught my child how to read better than his school.

Andrew February 21, 2008, 11:54 PM

I’m 14 and I have played the numerous games that are out there that involve Pokemon of some sort. Take it from me, Pokemon is not violent or evil. Your 6-year-old son is a little off on his definition of what Pokemon actually is. All of the 500-or-so Pokemon that Nintendo has made in the past year are not “ferocious, shape-shifting warriors with stunning powers to kill or be killed”. Trust me.

Hope this helps.

P.T. February 25, 2008, 6:48 AM

Pokémon is a Japanese Anime which is adapted from the handheld games. It’s fundamentally a Role-Playing game where a “trainer” (in other words, yourself) travels through a land searching for creatures which he may tame by capturing in a PokéBall. He may then use these in “battle” to lower an opponent’s health and cause it to “faint” (but not die) such as to win a battle. The card game is a basic derivative of the same idea, implemented differently. Also, the “mutations” that you have mentioned are actually “evolutions” when these creatures gain more powers and defence.

However unlike the “ferocious, shape-shifting warriors with stunning powers to kill or be killed” as has been described, the concept is none but the use of several “attacks” as previously described. In fact, as previously stated in the dubbed version of the Anime (which in fact is highly untrue to the original Japanese) states that no Pokémon is “evil” as such, but they become so under the influence of such evil teams as “Team Rocket” or “Team Galaxy”.

~~


Leave a reply:



(not displayed)

     




Avoid clicking "Post" more than once
Back to top >>
advertisement