Is "Twins Day" Cruel?

One mom thinks so. Here's why.

Momlogic's Gina: My kids' school is having "Twins' Day" today ... where one child in class dresses like another. The only problem: There are an odd number of kids in my son's class, and he doesn't have a "twin." Is this just cruel?
After school Friday, my son told my husband that he wasn't going to have a twin for Twins' Day because everyone in his class already had a twin. This was the first time we had even heard of Twins' Day ... the school didn't send a flier about it or anything.
I called the second-grade teacher to get more details. She suggested I call some of the other parents to see if my son could piggyback and be a "triplet." The idea of calling people I didn't know to tell them that my son had been left out wasn't too appealing. Plus, I don't even have their numbers! We ended the call with me feeling frustrated. I could tell that she thought I was overreacting, but I couldn't help it. The whole thing just made me incredibly upset.
The whole concept of Twins' Day reminds me of when the teacher used to allow the team captains to choose teams in gym class. One kid was always the last one standing. How incredibly humiliating for that child. What purpose does this serve?
The thought of sending my kid into class when all the other kids are dressed alike (but he's not) just made my heart break. I called a friend of mine to see what her son was wearing and I dressed my son in a similar outfit, even though they aren't in the same class. I figured that was better than nothing. But the bottom line is that I think Twins' Day is cruel. Do you?
The fact that the teacher didn’t seem concerned about it when you called upsets me more! She should have noticed DURING the twin groupings and helped him join as a “triplet” then!
I don’t know that I think it is cruel, but I do think it is stupid. Surely there can be some other kind of fun thing to do that doesn’t revolve around wearing the same clothes as someone else, I mean, what IS this?? And I agree with the above poster, what kind of teacher doesn’t take the time to figure out the logistics of this idea BEFORE the kids start to pair off??
If the school is going to do this, the school is responsible for pairing everybody up.
hey lady get over it and think about getting your kid in college and we wonder why we have problems with kids these days one day out of the year aint going to affect your kid. you’re just a sick sociopath.
These types of activities are meant to establish unity among students and boost their self esteem, but, when a child is so blatantly left out it lowers their self esteem and makes them feel as if they are not part of the group. It also, affects his/her emotional well being in a negative way that can be difficult to repair. Let’s face it, once something like this happens children are less likely to pick your child for future group activities and your child will be less likely to want to participate. This is a slippery slope and climbing back up can be difficult at best. In this case the teacher, knowing how many kids are in her class, should have planned to have groups of 2 & 3. Let’s say she didn’t realize this until your call to her…then she should have fixed the situation right away. Her salary is paid by the taxes that you pay. Therefore, she works for you. And if you tell her that what she is doing in class is not creating an emotionally healthy learning environment for your child then it is her JOB to fix the problem. If the situation is not fixed right away you should file a complaint with the principal and school district. I know that sounds extreme but clearly this teacher isn’t concerned with your child’s emotional well being and that is not the type of person that should be a teacher.
First off, I don’t know what Charles problem is…Why are there always so many men on this site? Secondly, as a twin myself I can tell you that I hated dressing the same as my twin. I also had an older sister and my mom would dress the 3 of us the same. YUK! I think this a stupid ideal completely.
I think anything that excludes one or a few children in a class is a bad idea. If the parent didn’t want their child to participate in an activity, that is one thing. But for the teacher to completely be unaware of the fact that one of the students was unmatched, and would be unmatched because of an odd number of students just goes to show her head is somewhere else. I would almost be tempted to keep my child home from school that day…although I am adamant about not skipping school for silly reasons, in this case my childs self esteem would be more important and I would take them for a day at a museum or something else educational, but fun.
I would have attached two faux legs to his shirt and sent him with his parasitic twin!!!
As an educator I know it is important to plan things to make sure everyone is included. If this teacher was going to have this activity done then it was her responsibility to make sure everyone was included. It is December and she knew from the start that her class had an odd number of students. Then for her to ask you to call another parent and ask to include your child was wrong. All of the details should have been taken care of BEFORE a situation happened. I think the situation should be brought to the attention of the administration. This will not create a healthy, unified classroom setting.
i am a twin, and i always hated twin day. in high school we had it as a themed day for homecoming week and people would always think because there dressed the same there like me and my sister or id get comments like “ha you dont have to dress up because you are a twin” it just felt demeaning.
My now homeschooled daughter had the same problem, she was always left out of these types of things at public school, that is part of the reason we decided to homeschool. She was a little bit behind her class so it was like she wasn’t important. She is much happier and her self-esteem is much better.
just don’t send him to school that day . my school never had a twin day but if he going to feel left out it probably be better not to go . in life someone is always going to be left out of something but teaching him that young doesn’t seem necessary.
Of course this situation would affect a child.
As humans we have this desire to fit in, in fact we spend most of our lives trying to “fit in” with society. We want to, in fact need to, be accepted. We are groomed from infants to tailor our behavior and our thinking to what is considered normal. If you grow up feeling unaccepted it can lead to serious problems as an adult.
In this case of the Twin day, although I’ve never heard of it, I truly fail to see the point in it. When I was reading the other comments someone mentioned that this exercise can be used for building unity amongst students. That sounds like a reasonable explanation, but even still there has to be another way to do this, such as class room t-shirts, or a project for the class or something that includes everyone.
For whatever reason the teacher didn’t properly plan to make sure everyone had a buddy, but adding him as a “triplet” would have made him feel left out just the same. When the teacher was made aware that your son didn’t have a partner, she could have and really should have rearranged the groups. She could have made groups of 3, or more or even divided the class into 2 halves, boys and girls. There were many options available to her and since she didn’t seem all that worried, then I would have gone to the Assistant Principal in the school about it and/or kept the child home so that there wouldn’t be hurt feelings.
It is the teachers fault! Most teachers would have been intelligent enough to know that there must be an even number of kids for this to work. So one child had to suffer due to the teachers stupidity. Glad she isn’t teaching my children!
Seriously, I’m assuming it’s like all the ones my kids’ schools have ever had. If it is just the classroom then I apologize and may agree with the comments, but schools do these things all the time as fun, dorky little activities for instance during spirit week. It’s not a big deal, and meant for fun, and having a twin in another classroom, or even grade, or none at all (kids forget a lot of times even, or don’t care), or being a set of “triplets”, “quads”, etc. is all fine and dandy. I think most situations (especially when kids are younger) arise as problems by how parents handle things. My kids used to go to a school with uniforms, spirit week meant out of uniform and forgetting twin day because of that was the only time any of my kids cared at all. It’s no big deal and most likely should have been handled like that. Your son is perhaps too young to realize it and felt that he HAD to have a twin like it was an assignment…
Again, if the situation was just in the classroom, and especially if there wasn’t any notice before, then that’s different. Really though, as parents part of our job is to show our kids how to react when life doesn’t go just how we want also…because that is a very important lesson everyone needs. :-)
First of all…CHARLES…why are you on a website for Mothers?? Men can be so insensitive!
I think that is so sad. Some teachers are so insensitive. The teacher should of took charge of the situation in class! She should of said that we are going to have one set of triplets!
I think that the teacher should of picked some1 for your son to be triplets w/. I hated when i was school & some1 got left out. I think thats horrible
Why didn’t the teacher offer to be the child’s twin. In my children’s school that would have happened. Even the parent could have dressed as the child’s twin.







My heart breaks for you. I have four kids and I know I would feel the same way. Since it is a school activity, they should have a guideline what teachers should do if they have an odd number. The teacher should have made sure that everyone had a group, especially for younger children.