twitter facebook stumble upon rss

The Real Deal on Concussions

sign up for the momlogic newsletter Tweet This

A new study published by the Official Journal of the American Academy of Pediatrics says that repeat concussions can result in decreased neurocognitive functioning, increased symptomatology, and, at times, catastrophic outcomes.

teen boys playing rugby

Last week, we reported on a study that had been released from the Center for the Study of Traumatic Encephalopathy (CSTE), at the Boston University School of Medicine, stating that repeated concussions can cause brain damage. That brain damage, known as chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), was detected in the brain tissue of former NFL players who died young -- some as early as their 30s or 40s. Researchers at the CSTE concluded former NFL player Tom McHale, who died in 2008 at the age of 45, as well as an 18-year-old athlete (the youngest case to date) who suffered multiple concussions, suffered from this brain damage as a result of their injuries.

But according to Gwenn Schurgin O'Keeffe, MD, FAAP, CEO and Editor-In-Chief of Pediatrics Now, the standard of care for concussions in kids is actually different from what was represented based on a January 2009 study on youth sports concussions.

The new 2009 study drives the point home that we need to do more than keep kids out of sports until the symptoms clear, which is how pediatricians used to manage concussions in the office, and how some still do in many parts of the country. The authors give a nice review of the landscape and past studies, concussion treatment theories and the many concussion grading systems and conclude that the only safe way to manage kids is a "stepwise return to play." This is borrowed form the professional sports model and has been done in elite youth sports for a while.

The reason a step wise return to play is so important is that it gives us time to truly evaluate a player and make sure that the increased activity is not to much on the healing brain. This builds in a safe buffer so when the player gets to the "game play" stage, we can be as sure as we can that the brain has healed from the original impact. Additionally, the report suggests we may have to consider neuropsychiatric testing and refer to neurologists much more than we are already doing, even for mild concussions. We used to think that if a child didn't lose consciousness we were good. Not so. Finally, and this we've known for a few years, the report emphasizes that the length of time benched is depended on how many prior concussions there have been in a child's past.

Also, it's well known in pediatrics that cheerleading is not a benign sport and is considered a "contact" sport due to the high injury rate of fractures and even head trauma. It turns out that cheerleaders have a 3.5% chance of getting a concussion and a very, very high likelihood of breaking a bone. Some of the worst dislocations and lacerations have been in cheerleaders.

see more photossee more photos
From Burly to GirlyCrushes: Then and Now

  • What Guys Really Did at Super Bowl
  • Superbowl Cheat Sheet
  • Ten Things I Love About Superbowl
  • Dip in to the Super Bowl

  • next: Tailgating: Super Bowl Style
    1 comments so far | Post a comment now
    steve February 2, 2009, 2:40 PM

    Their is no “healed” concussion truama is cumulative. Feeling better maybe, now we know the CTE is not going away no matter what age. With all the attention on the longterm affects of concussion more focus should be on prevention. The blow to the jaw, boxers “Glass Jaw”, the work of a local Tufts Temporal Mandibular Specialist, must be recognized when considering this type of concussion. Why do some athletes become “prone” to recurrence. A diagnosable marker in “prone” N.E. Patriot Players and random sampling of South Shore High school athletes have shown in three peer reviewed papers, to have a drastic reduction in recurrence in concussion from blows to the jaw. A Braintree soldier on his way to remove IED from the roads of Iraq has had this marker, a dime sized cartilage disc within the TMJ, corrected and has been fitted with the same orthotic retainer like mouth guard used by our local football team. Yet, the rest of his platoon will not be protected by this ADA approved oral protection, because the NFL and local institutions have not considered this procedure as real science. One peer reviewed paper stated, 30 kids had 50 concussions, when corrected and fitted, the same group had only three in the group. Another reads, 12 N.E. Patriot players with multiple concussions, one reports four, after fitting none reported. Dementia Pugilistica or CTP related brain disease is thought to be a result of repeated jaw blows. One player in the B.U. study who wore this device and has no reported CPT, it was stated on WEEI, “I don’t have those white spots on my brain”, another CPT suffer repeatedly comments, one on CNN “I got kicked in the chin”. This marker within the jaw joint may be the mechanism that triggers the point of origin for this type of concussion. Blows to the spinal cord and crown of the head, are a different type of trauma. This
    “superior” method of constructing a biomechnic correction is clearly a better way of addressing concussion with a multidisciplinary approach to concussion awareness. Waiting for a child to have a concussion, is foolish, any known means of prevention must be considered. With a history of use within the NFL for over two decades, now being reviewed by the NHL medical committee and a subject of controversy with the commissioner of the NFL. More attention must be put on this device now thought to be one way of reducing MTBI in our troops.

    Back to top >>