twitter facebook stumble upon rss

Did Casey Contribute to Another Death?

sign up for the momlogic newsletter Tweet This

An Orlando 911 operator lectured a kidnap victim for wasting resources, comparing the situation to the futile search for Caylee Anthony. She later died.


The people who actually believe Casey Anthony's story that her daughter Caylee was kidnapped by a woman named Zenaida Gonzalez are few. But Anthony's fabrication has become so well known in the Orlando area that it might have even contributed to the death of a Florida woman.

When Loyta Sloley called 911 on January 27 to report she was being held against her will, the 911 dispatcher informed her she was "wasting his time." He then went on to lecture the mother of one about how she was taking up police resources. He told her she might have to pay for the police search, and even compared the situation to the futile search for Caylee Anthony:

"We're going to be launching a major search for you and you could be charged with all that expense if you don't cooperate with me. We have to look for you just like we did the little girl that was missing."

Tragically, Loyta Sloley, 34, was later found murdered in a hotel room, killed by her ex-boyfriend James Clayton, who then took his own life.

Could Caylee's alleged kidnapping have set a precedent in the Florida community to be wary of false kidnapping reports? To date, there's never been any evidence to bolster the argument Caylee was kidnapped, as Cindy Anthony frantically reported in her July 911 call.

The reference to Caylee's alleged kidnapping in the Loyta Sloley 911 call is particularly devastating because yesterday it was reported that new evidence concludes Zenaida Gonzalez doesn't even exist.

According to a local Florida news station, in the month-long period between the time Caylee was last seen and the day her disappearance was reported to police, Casey Anthony's cell phone records show she never once made a call to or received a call from someone named Zenaida Gonzalez.

Boyfriend Wiretap Casey Cries Casey Interview Casey Texts
Meter Reader Hoover Interview Redacted Statements Text Messages

Casey Anthony Photo Bucket

See Also:

next: Morning-After Pill Available to Teens
28 comments so far | Post a comment now
Sally March 25, 2009, 9:55 PM

What strikes me is the difference between Cindy and Casey’s voices on the 911 Call. Cindy is so hysterical she can hardly talk. Casey is cool as a cucumber sounding as if she was reporting a pencil missing. It’s amazing how cold and calculating Casey sounds as she makes up the story that she got a phone call from Zenaida and talked to Caylee that day, July 15. She was trying to establish that Caylee was alive so when the body was found she couldn’t be to blame. It’s no surprise to me that Casey’s cell phone records show no calls to a Zenaida Gonzalez. The police knew on July 16 when they arrested Caylee that the nanny did not exist. They also knew from the smell of death in the car trunk that Caylee was dead and Casey likely murdered her. The evidence keeps piling up until it is likely to bury her. You can see from Baez’s little performance in court today shouting, “My client is innocent,” that he is playing for the cameras. Notice how he is slimming down like he was an actor in Law and Order. Is he angling for his own TV show? Does he plan to replace Judge Judy as Judge Jose? Casey Anthony innocent? No way Jose.

white oleander March 25, 2009, 10:40 PM

sigh…i am tired of baez….he gives me the creeps and it is obvious he does not know what he is doing…..

i am wondering how george and cindy are paying their bills….george looked happy at the hearing today….

Linda March 25, 2009, 11:02 PM

He is probably feeling the beginnings of his antidepressants. It usually takes them 6-8 wks. to be completely in the system and begin working well. Noticed Cindy kept her face away from the camera in court today. Very obvious! She is ashamed since the dish on her flirting came out. Thank God, keep it coming, so we won’t have to look at her face or hear her hysteria. WooHoo!

melissa March 25, 2009, 11:19 PM

It is such a shame when you hear about stories like this were someone needed help and they didn’t get it. Granted the operator probably gets many prank calls in a day. That does not change the fact that it is not his job to decide who is genuine and who is lying. He is paid to take calls and help so that is what he should do.

Kelly March 26, 2009, 8:10 AM

I have to agree with Melissa on this one. What right did the 911 operator have to decide that the woman was lying? If anyone is to blame for this woman’s death it would be the operator who classified her as a prankster, or liar, whichever you choose. As for Casey, she is guilty as sin and deserves more than any punishment she will receive in a court of law.

JKH March 26, 2009, 10:47 AM


Anonymous March 26, 2009, 11:18 AM

caylees mother murdeered hre, when she went to a bar 1 night she put caylee in a garbage bag then left her there for a while..little innocent caylee was murdered by her alcaholic mother

sunshine March 26, 2009, 11:49 AM

Maybe someone can answer my question? I was just reading an article about Hoovers deposition. He stated that ABC paid Baez 200,000 dollars for home videos. And he also stated that he thought that Dominac Casey got the tip to look for Caylee back in November from a family member.Is this correct??

CBoldrey March 26, 2009, 1:02 PM

Yes, the PI’s for the family were in the woods bout 25 yrads from the body just a month prior to it being found. Oneof the PI’s told the other, “We are going to get Caylee.” The other asked if she was alive and the first replied no. So yes, I do believe they were tipped off.

allison March 26, 2009, 1:19 PM

I agree with CBOLD because how in the world would the PI know to look there?? Seriously! Of course he was tipped off.. probably by Uncle Lee..SICKO

sunshine March 26, 2009, 1:28 PM

That was my question. I thought he originally said it was a pyschic that tipped him off. Now, he says it was a family member. Can’t the family be held liable??? I would think they would in a major way!!!!

allison March 26, 2009, 1:35 PM

He was probably paid by the Scamthonys to not tell because they wouldnt want to be held liable. Thats why he said it was the psychic. Remember that the PI and Cindy had a “flirty relationship”.

katie March 26, 2009, 4:05 PM

CIndy hid her face.. because..she should be embarrassed.. selling pix and videos of her deceased beautiful grandchild to support her lying daughters defense team… WHAT GRANDMOTHER WOULD DO THAT????? i have said.. grandma Plesea said.. “i wonder if Casey hated Cindy more than she loved Caylee”.. i Say.. ” i wonder if CINDY believes in Casey more than she loved Caylee”..obviously.. shes using the murder of that child as a money maker to support Bozo baez and his dream team.. defending her lying daughter!! Shame on you, cindy!!

mercaties March 27, 2009, 2:47 AM

I’am absolutly sick or hearing stories (I recently watched a MSNBC special on this)about people dying or nearly dying due to stupid neglegent 911 operators. This 911 operator should face jail time as well as loose his job if he hasn’t allready. Even if she was lying which apparently she was not that was not his call to make. My understanding is that a 911 operators job is to take the call and notify the proper people (fire, ambulance, police) Also, He had no buisness refering to the Caylee Anthony case it had nothing to do with why this woman was calling. I think this 911 operator should face obstruction charges. I think that every 911 call needs to be monitored by a second party. There has got to be more laws here. In my town, a house was broken into and the husband was shot by the burgler the wife called 911 frantically and the 911 operator actually said “are you sure it’s life threatining were really backed up tonight?” and she kept asking the wife where he was shot, the wife said she couldn’t tell because there was so mutch blood everywhere and the 911 operator actually got snippy and said “how can you not tell where he’s bleeding from?” Needless to say, he passed away because of the length of time it took the 911 operator to notify paramedics. Very Sad!

Squirt March 27, 2009, 9:10 AM

Casey Anthony had absolutely nothing to do with this young woman’s death. To even bring her into this is nothng short of disgusting. How can she be tied to this at all? So what if the 911 operator mentioned it? It is HIS fault that the woman is dead, not Casey’s. I absolutely agree that he should be held liable and that it is his job to send out police, not question whether some one is telling the truth. I hope he rots in jail and her family sues for as much as they can!

Cassie March 27, 2009, 9:34 AM

I know this doesn’t have anything to do with the article about Loyta Sloley. But in the audio attached to this article in the 911 call Cindy said she hasn’t seen Caylee since the 7th of June. That’s not true she took Caylee up to see her [Cindys] father June 15(?) Fathers Day. Why can’t anyone in that family keep there lies straight? Casey killed Caylee for sure, everyone needs to realize that.

Squirt March 27, 2009, 10:58 AM

let’s all stick to the point in question. Did Casey contribute to this woman’s death? Who honestly agrees with that insanity?

chris March 27, 2009, 12:23 PM

why do white women their kids ? i think white women who kill their kids are possesed seriously i can never have a kid with a white women i can t trust them and they can t cook white women are just for sex thats all !!!

allison March 27, 2009, 12:54 PM

Hey Chris?? Why are you on momlogic anyway?? Maybe you should go on something like espn

Sally March 27, 2009, 1:25 PM

Cassie, Cindy was hysterical on the 911 call and couldn’t think straight. I’ve had to call 911 about an emergency and when someone’s life is in danger, the last thing I could remember was dates. It was difficult for Casey to even remember Caylee’s birth date. I don’t believe she was lying about the date. She just didn’t remember the exact date until she gave the sheriff’s department the video of Caylee on her great grandfather’s lap and it was stamped June 15. It’s interesting Casey didn’t remember the exact date she killed Caylee but she knew the exact number of days since she murdered Caylee. It was exactly 31 days from June 16, the last day Caylee was reported seen by George to July 15 when the 911 call was made. It’s interesting how a sociopath’s mind works.

Back to top >>