sign up for the momlogic newsletter

Mother Says School Work Sheet is Racist

Monday, November 23, 2009
filed under: celebration logic

PhillyBurbs.com When she was helping her son with his homework Saturday night, a Central Bucks mother noticed something that surprised and shocked her.

racist math worksheet

"I couldn't understand what I was looking at," said the woman, whose identity the newspaper has agreed not to disclose.

It was a work sheet called "Solving Equations using Multiplication and Division!" and it featured a photo of a black man wearing a straw hat, shirt and suspenders, with his mostly toothless mouth wide open. As if to underscore the man's stupidity, at the bottom of the picture was written, "No wai!!!"

The mother learned that her son, the only black student in his eighth-grade pre-algebra class at Lenape Middle School, was teased by another student when the assignment was distributed.

"One of the kids in the classroom turned around and said, 'Is that your father?' " she said.

"We are highly insulted and offended. We sent him to school to learn pre-algebra. He should be protected from this stuff, not have it thrown in his face...He gets enough (racial slurs) and negativity from the kids. To have the teacher encourage it?"

Both the mother and her son are black. On Monday, the student stayed home from school and his mother called the principal first thing in the morning.

Lenape Middle School principal Nick Chubb said administrators are thoroughly investigating the matter, and he could not comment further until the investigation is complete.

School district spokeswoman Karen Smith said the math teacher, Matthew Curran, frequently uses photos and other illustrations on his work sheets to engage the students.

Curran reported, through Smith, that he found the image by doing a Google Images search for the phrase "multiply and divide."

"I chose it because it said 'no way,' which is a comment my students make when I require them to show each calculation," he wrote in an e-mail. "I had no idea that I might offend anyone. I am very sorry for any distress that this has caused my students and the community."

The boy's mother said she spent much of the weekend angry and in tears.

"It's very stressful to be an African-American in the community and you want to fit in and you want to embrace all of the things Central Bucks offers you," she said. "Who's protecting us here?"

Monday night, after meeting with the boy's family, NAACP Bucks County President John Jordan issued a written statement denouncing the events.

"It brings into question whether all of our children are being provided a safe and fair environment in which to learn. What happened here is unacceptable, and we will take steps to make sure it never happens again."

NAACP Bucks County Executive Committee members plan to meet with the principal and the teacher involved in the incident at Lenape Middle School "in hopes of amicably resolving the issue," the statement went on to say.

When the assignment was handed out to the class, several students expressed their disapproval of the picture, according to the NAACP. But the teacher told them to do the work anyway, according to the boy's mother.

She asked her son why he didn't leave the class.

"He said, 'Mommy, I'm in school.' He knows the rules. He has to follow the rules," she said. "He's trying to get on the honor roll right now."

The woman doesn't understand why the photo was even included on the math work sheet.

"This has nothing to do with math," she said.

A Google Images search for "multiply and divide" provides other images that might be considered more math-related - a cartoon drawing of a child holding math symbols, a cartoon calculator with legs and various photos of calculators.

The boy's mother thinks his teacher should have chosen a different image for the work sheet, and needs to be careful to choose appropriate images in the future.

She plans to keep her son home from school until she feels as though it's safe to send him again.

"Racism is usually so subtle. To have it so blatant is what is so shocking," she said. "Hopefully, we can all learn from this and move forward in a positive way - for everyone, not just the black kids or the Hispanic kids or the Jewish kids or the other subgroups ... We need some peace and understanding. I don't want hate."



previous: It's Barbie in a Burkha
next: Dreaming of Reality

filed under: celebration logic

18 comments so far | Post a comment now >>

 
It’s funny.
- Coral
Posted 11/23/09 11:42 AM
 
I understand why she would be hurt, but by carrying on and dragging everyone and the NAACP into it, she has made it worse. If she had just let it slide, it would be forgotten by now. She could have just said something to the teacher the first time, and then if it happened again, then called the principal. But by making, literally, a federal case out of it, she’s made it ridiculous. God forbid someone might have to deal with something stressful in their lives….we all do and we all get through it. She is teaching her kid to be a big crybaby when things don’t go perfectly.
- Just Sayin'
Posted 11/23/09 11:49 AM
 
This is ridiculous. There are real issues going on in the world. The picture in questions is a graphic that is all over the internet, and if anyone should be involved, it should be the ADA. The picture is funny because he’s missing all of his teeth and has a crazy look on his face, hence the use of it in a mathematical homework sheet. It’s funny. I think if we’re going to involve the NAACP, we should also involve the ADA and the NCH considering the fact that the man is toothless and homeless. In fact, I’m going to file a lawsuit against the mother because her behavior and actions are offensive to me.
- Big Mama
Posted 11/23/09 12:25 PM
 
Are you serious? It should have been ignored??? What does that photo have to do with math? The poor child was ridiculed. I hope the teacher has learned a valuable lesson. The mother isn’t teaching her child to be a crybaby. She’s teaching him to stand up for what is right.
- Julie
Posted 11/23/09 12:30 PM
 
This photo is an internet sensation, not because the man is black but because of how ridiculous he looks. It’s unfortunate that the kid made the comment about his father, but I feel like his classmate is the only person guilty of insensitivity and racism here. I know a lot of young teachers, and it can be hard for them to find a way to engage their students. Furthermore a lot of them are of my generation (mid-80’s babies). We are the first wave of young adults that were brought up on the internet. This teacher was just sharing something funny he found on google, he’s not a racist nor is he trying to single anyone out. Had the man in the picture been white I’m sure he would have used it as well. This woman’s initial reaction is understandable, but she should have realized it was just more teasing from another kid (the same way fat kids get teased, kids with glasses get teased, etc etc) and moved on with her life.
- Steve
Posted 11/23/09 12:44 PM
 
I think the mother is more upset than her child, as shown in her over reaction to the situation. I do not believe the child’s safety was ever at risk!!!! Children of all different backgrounds will recieve redicule from other children, it is a part of growing up. What about the children with fathers who have passed away? The ones who dont know who their father is? The ones with two fathers? As life goes on and more is learned about a person, the comments can become more personal and be much more hurtful. SO advice to the mother- keep your child at home for the rest of his life! THIS IS NOT THE WORST NOR THE LAST comment your child will receive in his life. In fact this situation will most likely make for some great ridicule later on down the road
- Chris
Posted 11/23/09 01:11 PM
 
Funny picuture…I don’t think it was meant to be racist but these days you can’t call a crayon black without someone screaming racism.
- not p.c.
Posted 11/23/09 01:12 PM
 
The teacher that says that she didn’t think anyone would be offended is lacking in the common sense department. I’m a white woman and if my son brought that picture home, I would be VERY offended. I would’ve called the principal immediately.
- angie
Posted 11/23/09 01:14 PM
 
Calling a black crayon black isn’t rasict. But I do refer to m Ritz as cracker as honkie crackers.
- Keepin it real
Posted 11/23/09 02:11 PM
 
Who is this mom to judge the man in the picture, and say that he is anything less than her. This man obviously had no problem having his picture taken, why should this mom have a problem with his picture. What I hear her saying, is this man(in the picture)doesn’t deserve respect enough to be able to have his picture included on the math homework. Embrace who you are as the man in the picture has. If the man had been white, yellow, red or any other color, would this have been an issue?
- julie
Posted 11/23/09 03:18 PM
 
Angie, are you offended by keepin it real reference to you as a honkie? And to keepin it real - why is it okay for you to be racist toward whites and used racist names?
- chris
Posted 11/23/09 05:29 PM
 
Yeah, it is racist and offensive. And the reason the teacher thought it was funny because he’s not black. When you’re the only black kid in class, and the someone selects a photo that someone could jokingly refer to you as their father because of similarity of colour rather than actual resemblance, it’s not funny. It’s hurtful. Is it possible that people could just actually picture themselves in someone else’s shoes for a change. Let’s say it’s an all male class and the female student gets a picture of a topless woman who NO WAI! on the cover of her exam? Hey, now that’s funny!
- deathstar
Posted 11/23/09 07:09 PM
 
While I don’t think that the teacher probably intended to be offended, I do think it was appropriate for the mother to get upset and act on the situation. This image IS racially offensive. To those of you saying it’s not; get a clue! We have a long history in the country of depicting black people as stupid and ridiculous. It is completely unacceptable to use an image that furthers these hurtful and dated stereotypes, especially in the classroom. If I were the mother of a child in this class, let alone a black child, I would be mad as hell about the ignorance demonstrated by this teacher. I don’t know whether it is appropriate to keep her child out of school for a prolonged period of time, but I can understand why this is a big deal to her.
- Jessica
Posted 11/23/09 07:26 PM
 
Whether intended racism or not, I think the mother should have first discussed this with the teacher and then if she was not satisfied after the conversation, she should have gone to the principal, and then if the school didn’t address her concerns appropriately or it started happening again and again, then take it to the superintendent level, but involving the NAACP early on? Sheesh. The mother should be a mother and teach her son how to solve problems through direct conversation, not by immediately running to the NAACP and act like a victim. It teaches the son he is helpless and needs someone else to solve his problems. They are incapable of taking this on themselves. People need to stop playing victims and deal with issues head on. I am white, and I have been discriminated against by black people. Yes, it happens, but you rarely hear about it. I was also bullied on a day-to-day basis in junior high school for two years but I dealt with it. Kids say hurtful things all the time. But I learned early on that I am no one’s victim. The best thing that mom could have done was teach her son that he doesn’t have to be a victim either, but she missed the opportunity.
- Sally
Posted 11/23/09 10:20 PM
 
There is also a long history of people thinking the people who live out in the country (ie…hillbillies, rednecks, good ole country boys etc…) are dumb so I guess it would have been racist to use a white person too.
- Anonymous
Posted 11/24/09 05:00 AM
 
In order to have used the picture, the teacher would have gone through five pages of Google Image results, all of which included more appropriate images for the classroom. Absolutely inexcusable.
- jag
Posted 11/24/09 07:02 AM
 
I am so tired of all of the reverse form of racial anything it is gettint to be all right to declare your self black but not white it is ok for the blasck community to habe the NAACP but not for the whites to have the NAAWP almost on a dialy form I see some one declaring racial profiling or some tyope of injustice enough is enought I am white and damn proud of it I am also a assrian swedish person but first I am an american lets start there drop all of the surnames Like African _American or Jewish_American what ever it is almost getting to the point of trying to start trouble all over again
- chuck
Posted 11/28/09 10:21 PM
 
Sounds to me like the black woman was the only one complaining. I see a trend here.
- Burt Fisher
Posted 12/04/09 06:16 AM
(not displayed)
  remember me?      
 

Avoid clicking “Post” more than once.

resources
experts guides
bloggers staff
newsletter videos
games twitter
advertisement

Win a $5000 Hershey's Diamond Pendant!
Enter Here

Win a $5000 Hershey's Diamond Pendant!

enter here

community

Join the Momlogic community!

 

momlogic community logo

 

Sign Up
Login
Enter without joining

coupons       More special offers     momsview coupons  

Amby Baby Motion Beds/Hammocks Recalled

find out more