twitter facebook stumble upon rss

Baking Ban In NYC Schools

sign up for the momlogic newsletter Tweet This

Yesterday, moms and their kids turned out in droves to protest a pending ordinance that will all but forbid the sale of home-baked goods in New York City public schools. We got a few passionate foodie-mom protesters to weigh in.

bake sale

momlogic's Vivian: Bake sales have long been a fundraising tradition at schools. But with pending Chancellor Regulation A-812, New York Department Of Education (DOE) officials will succeed in banishing anything home-baked from being sold in schools between the hours of 8 AM and 6 PM (with the exception of one PTA-sponsored endeavor per month) -- while permitting the sale of less-healthy prepackaged goods (like Doritos). All of this comes under the guise of fighting childhood obesity, since quantifiable nutritional values are displayed on packaged goods.

Depending on how often your school holds a bake sale, the ordinance might not seem all bad. A New York Times article says, "Students may sell fresh fruits and vegetables, or one of 27 specific packaged items that have been approved for sales in city vending machines, between the start of school and 6 PM on weekdays. The same goes for parent groups, except for an exception carved out for one no-brownies-barred Parent Teacher Association bake sale during the school day per month."

But many parents are PEEVED by this ordinance, and to make sure their voices were heard, they held a "Bake-In" yesterday at Manhattan's City Hall Park in protest.

"At the heart of it, their priorities are really askew," says Jennifer Perillo, food blogger and consulting food editor at Working Mother magazine. "Parents aren't asking to host more bake sales. What we're asking is for the New York Department Of Education to make sensible choices about the food our children are consuming when they are on school grounds.

"At our school," Perillo continues, "the PTA is sanctioning the sale of ice cream in our schoolyard, without offering parents a healthful option, like fresh fruit or vegetables. Instead of saying, 'You can't have homemade foods,' why don't they ban these processed foods? It would force parents and officials to look outside of the literal package box and offer more healthful alternatives when raising money for school. With this ruling, the DOE is just giving them more license to offer unhealthy options to our children."

Another mom-pal, child-nutrition expert Erin Patterson, also sees this ordinance as backward. "With the exception of Duncan Hines mixes, home-baked goods are far superior to packaged goods, because they're made from real ingredients," she says. "Packaged foods are loaded with chemicals and processed ingredients. I believe in whole food, and Doritos are not whole food. That's why I'm all fired up about this. I feel the whole problem in our nation is because we live on processed foods. I believe they did this ruling to control childhood obesity through managing fat content, but it's such bullshit to me. Healthful eating isn't always just about fat content. I don't know if they're getting money from these companies (like Frito-Lay), or what. And there's something so personal about selling food that you've baked with your kids. I saw a rally sign that said, "Baking Is Educational" -- and that's true. It's science, math and creativity, which is a huge plus for our kids."

Now, I'm no Betty Crocker -- and if I do any baking for school, there's a damn good chance it came out of a box. But on the other hand, if someone has the time, heart and desire to create delish home-baked goods for my kid to chow down on, I'm the last person to stand in their way -- especially if my school can fiscally reap the benefits.

Have you come across any similar rules and regulations on prepackaged school foods where you live? What are your thoughts on the subject?


next: Lawsuit Claims Boy Scouts Sex Abuse Coverup
790 comments so far | Post a comment now
Anonymous March 19, 2010, 6:32 PM

Let ‘em eat cake!

Come On Now! March 19, 2010, 8:59 PM

Things are getting so out of control. EVERYTHING is being ‘banned’. I feel like I’m living in V For Vendetta anymore… Parents, when I was a kid I would buy everything at the bake sales, to the point of stomach aches! But, I was never even close to obese. Because, bake sales and cookies dont make your kids obese as seldom as they come around. Maybe you should watch what you are putting on your dinner table and be a parent when it comes to your childs eating habits at home, and let them (and my non-obese children who I monitor and parent) enjoy their damn cookies!

BelieveJay March 21, 2010, 12:08 AM

This is the first protest in favor of a fundraiser I have ever heard about :)

What’s funny is I completely understand this has nothing to do with people wanting to support fundraising. It’s not even really about bake sales.

As implied above, it would appear to be more about the lack of home baked quality goods in the school system. The proliferation of processed foods taking precidence over, and replacing whole foods in schools almost entirely.

I do think there is an issue here to address or before long, schools won’t have cafeterias with ovens and mixers at all but instead will have big walk in freezers and lots of microwaves.



MURRAYMaritza July 15, 2010, 4:39 AM

All people deserve very good life time and loan or small business loan can make it better. Because people’s freedom depends on money.

nfl jerseys July 26, 2010, 6:26 PM

I agree with the author of this post here

Doofedaregolo August 21, 2010, 10:03 PM

I enjoyed reading your blog. Keep it that way.

bruce September 1, 2010, 3:37 AM

this is clearly not acceptable. if home baked foods has been a fund raiser then it should have been let to continue that way. this ban may lead to the some livelihood also.

with regards
social bookmarking service

Ivana Watkins September 28, 2010, 8:31 PM

Very interesting points. Thanks!

Willodean Galam September 28, 2010, 9:45 PM

These are some great points!

Tanner Sheinbein September 29, 2010, 5:36 AM

“Hello. That’s type of an “”unconventional”” query , but produce other company requested you the way get the menu bar to show up like you’ve acquired attained it? I even contain a weblog and am really searching to alter across the theme, on the other hand am afraid to dying to mess with it for concern of the major engines like google punishing me. I’m extremely new to all of this .
..so i am basically not constructive exactly how one can attempt to to it all yet. I will simply keep functioning on it sooner or later at a time Thank you for any help you perhaps can provide right here.”

Fedyodondix October 4, 2010, 4:45 AM


United States Restaurant Guide - a guide to every restaurant, http://restaurants-us.com/ia/Toledo/Dairy%20Queen/52342/

conference call skype October 14, 2010, 1:57 PM

I keep listening to the news speak about getting free online grant applications so I have been looking around for the best weblog to get one.:)

Themes for Vista October 18, 2010, 10:12 AM

Hey, I just hopped over to your site via StumbleUpon. Not somthing I would normally read, but I liked your thoughts none the less. Thanks for making something worth reading.

Kneemastoothe October 18, 2010, 3:25 PM


the Federal-State Unemployment Insurance Program provides unemployment benefits to eligible workers . http://insuranceinstates.com/tennessee/Chattanooga/Unum/37402/

diet menu October 20, 2010, 2:12 PM

Gracias por sus comentarios perspicaces. Espero visitar su sitio blog en breve.

sniper games October 24, 2010, 7:57 PM

When are you going to post again? You really entertain me!

Kerry Tiehen October 24, 2010, 11:23 PM

My brother and I were just discussing this particular very topic, he is normally attempting to prove me wrong. Your view on this is excellent and just how I truly feel. I just now sent my brother this site to show him your own view. After overlooking your blog I bookmarked and will be coming back to read your messages!

Mad Men October 25, 2010, 10:56 AM

I take pleasure in the opinions on this website, it really gives it that community experience!

Thomasena Mcmichael October 25, 2010, 5:58 PM

I am invariably trying to find somebody to alternative articles with, I am a university student and also have a blog right here on our campus web-site. The subject of your respective website and writting fashion would go great in a few of my category’s, let me know should you be up for this.

Valeria Caneva October 26, 2010, 6:05 PM

Seeing some of your posts I truly found this specific one to generally be very good. I’ve got a weblog as well and want to repost some snips of your respective articles in my own weblog. Would it be okay if I do this as long I reference your webblog or build a one way link to your posting I procured the snip from? If not I am aware of and would not do it with out your approval . I have book marked the write-up to twitter in addition to zynga accounts intended for reference. Nevertheless thanks either way!


Back to top >>
advertisement