twitter facebook stumble upon rss

Haiti Needs Help, Not Baby Bottles

sign up for the momlogic newsletter Tweet This

Guest blogger Kate Tuttle: The generosity of average people after a natural disaster -- even one occurring thousands of miles away -- is truly inspiring. In the wake of the devastating earthquake in Haiti last January, we've witnessed acts of enormous caring, from doctors and nurses volunteering their time to construction workers traveling to help rebuild Port au Prince to everyday moms and dads sending donations of food, clothing and money. And the recent news that cholera -- a potentially deadly waterborne illness -- has now come to Haiti has sparked another round of giving. But charity isn't always so simple, and one of the most commonly requested donations -- baby bottles and formula -- can hurt far more than it helps, according to international aid workers.

The reason is simple: Breastfeeding, which is the best option for babies under any circumstances, becomes even more crucial when mothers and infants are in post-disaster situations, where clean water is nearly impossible to come by. Without clean water, bottles and nipples become vectors for disease, as does powdered formula prepared with dirty water. Once a baby begins feeding with formula, breastfeeding's delicate supply-and-demand loop is interrupted, and it's all too common for a nursing mother to find her supply waning. (Supply does not seem to be an issue in cases where mothers themselves are underfed and even dehydrated. Mother Nature seems to know how to provide for babies.) 

While formula is often donated at first, once breastfeeding is interrupted, mothers scramble to get formula they may not be able to afford, which leads to women "stretching" it by mixing it with more than the prescribed amount of water, which can cause illness and even death. For all these reasons, aid workers caution against sending baby bottles and/or formula. In the very rare cases that a baby is left motherless, they say, the use of formula to feed that baby can and should be handled by care workers on the local level (UNICEF, for instance, which has been in Haiti since before the disaster). 

Every time this issue comes up, it seems to provoke another round of online comment wars, in which America's love-hate relationship with breastfeeding is invoked, someone accuses the aid workers of being "boob Nazis" and so on. I wish we could get past that fight, because what happens in a country like Haiti is not about the issues so many American women bring to the topic of breastfeeding. It's unarguable that breast milk is babies' preferred food source, but American infants do just fine on formula. That's because we have dishwashers, refrigerators and clean water supplies -- three things that the average Haitian mother can only dream of at this point. (Oh, and enough money to buy the stuff.) 

For mothers and babies whose lives are not like ours, there is no better health insurance plan than this: Provide them with shelter and food, and protect nursing mothers from helpful donations that will end up hurting them (and from the formula manufacturers, for whom every natural disaster represents a new market they'd love to get into).

next: Holiday Design Tips from Nate Berkus!
6 comments so far | Post a comment now
Kellie November 30, 2010, 11:11 AM

A unique perspective on how donations without education can wreck more havoc after a disaster. Clean water is the key and sustainable solutions like water wells (and breastmilk!)are needed.

Christy November 30, 2010, 1:32 PM

These are excellent points, but I do take some issue with the idea that Americans have a love/hate relationship with breastfeeding. Are there any significant numbers of people who hate breastfeeding on principle? No. But there may be significant numbers of mothers who hate lactivists making them feel bad about their choices (or lack thereof). I don’t think it’s even relevant to the post. The reasons why formula are not ideal in these circumstances are clear. Rather than stirring up more debate (and making this an attack on formula companies), how about putting put some recommendations for things people should donate?

Kate Tuttle November 30, 2010, 3:37 PM

Christy, I’m glad you liked the piece overall. I guess my point about the love/hate relationship with breastfeeding is that this is a country in which all the medical authorities tout its benefits and say it should be promoted, but then allow hospitals to undercut that message by providing free formula samples to mothers even before their babies are born, and the government mandates a very short, unpaid maternity leave, etc.

As for attacking formula companies, I’ll never apologize for that! I definitely don’t want to demonize formula-feeding moms or their babies, but the formula companies exploit women to make money, period.

I’d go to the international red cross site if seeking ideas for how to give. Typically they recommend money to a charity with boots-on-the-ground experience, like red cross or Partners in Health. Everyone wants to help by giving old clothes, but what I’ve read is that they are more trouble than they’re worth, in terms of international giving (still very much needed at the local level, though!)

michelle December 2, 2010, 9:17 AM

This is a very old issue and has been a problem for years in Africa and other areas with unsafe water supplies. You mentioned that bottles and formula are among “the most commonly requested donations” but that international aid workers are warning against this. So then who is doing the “request”ing? You need to go further and say why so often international aid is driven by the agendas of US corporations, rather than the actual need on the ground. This isn’t limited to the formula companies; the US government often requires that any food aid it distributes overseas come from US producers. Which, incidentally, prevents local farmers/manufacturers from competing at all, and therefore keeps these places in the kind of deep poverty that requires food aid.

immigration services  February 10, 2011, 7:14 PM

Hello. splendid job. I did not imagine this. This is a excellent story. Thanks!

mockingjay March 15, 2011, 2:33 PM

Lovely website! I am loving it!! Will come back again. I am taking your feeds also. %WEBSITE%

Back to top >>